Dirty Old Town: Folk anthem’s lost verse to be revealed

An unheard verse of Ewan MacColl’s Dirty Old Town is to be given a one-off airing by his widow.

A long-lost verse of one of folk music’s most famous songs is to be unveiled by the widow of its creator nearly 75 years after it was first sung.

Dirty Old Town was written by Salford-born folk legend Ewan MacColl for Landscape With Chimneys, his 1949 play about his home city.

Since then, the song has taken on a life of its own, being covered by everyone from rockers Black Rebel Motorcycle Club and Frank Black to country stars Steve Earle and Townes Van Zandt and has even formed the basis of a terrace chant about Liverpool defender Virgil van Dijk.

But it will be given a new lease of life by American singer Peggy Seeger, who married MacColl in 1977, when she reveals a new verse in a one-off performance at Salford’s We Invented the Weekend festival in June.

‘Much loved’

She said it would be great for people who knew the song well to hear the verse, which MacColl abandoned in 1951, but admitted it “isn’t that good”.

“The words are fine, but they just don’t scan if you sing it,” she said.

“It was written as part of the play, but like a lot of art, if it doesn’t work, you drop it.”

Getty Images Children playing in Salford in 1951Getty Images

Nevertheless, it will give a new lease of life to a song which has long since become part of the public consciousness, thanks to a pair of covers released by Irish bands almost two decades apart.

All ready much-loved by folk devotees, the song was given an overhaul by The Dubliners in 1968, before being reworked again by The Pogues in 1985.

However, Seeger said she was not impressed with their versions.

“I don’t like what The Dubliners did to it, I don’t like what The Pogues did to it – I think they have lost the loneliness,” she said.

“I think they have lost the confusion of a young person walking through it.

“To me, Ewan was reliving his 20s and his late teens so I think it is harder to change.”

Such was the success of both versions however that many now assume the song is about Dublin.

Seeger said that while it was firmly about the city in which MacColl grew up, she could understand how it fitted other cities.

“It speaks to everybody from a dirty old broken down industrial city,” she said.

“I have no doubt if a Scots band had recorded it, Glasgow people would say it is theirs.

“But Salford was in Ewan MacColl’s bones.

“He took me to his dirty old town within a week of our three-decade partnership.”

Peggy Seeger
Seeger said MacColl would have been “very surprised and very pleased” by the song’s continued success

 

She said 75 years after it was first written to accompany set changes in MacColl’s play, it remained “a perfect song”.

“It’s a beautiful melody, just four economical verses, and it has been covered by hundreds of singers each in their own way,” she said.

There are personal memories too of the song for Seeger.

“It’s special because as part of his courtship ritual Ewan McColl brought me to Salford to show what the Dirty Old Town was, because up to that time the only slums I had ever been were the black slums in Washington DC except in DC we already had a throwaway society,” she said.

“The streets of Salford were spotless maybe because the women scrubbed their steps in the morning.”

She said part of its appeal lay in its language, which was at times unlike what most folk music was offering at the time.

But as he had been an ardent left wing activist since joining in a mass trespass on Kinder Scout to claim the right to roam on private land in 1932, MacColl was not the average folk musician.

“The words ‘I’m going to get me a big sharp axe’ aren’t very folk music, but they speak to his concerns about the struggle of working class people,” she said.

Ewan McColl
Ewan McColl wrote the song to accompany set changes in his play
She added that the continued appeal of the song would have delighted her late husband.

“I think he would be very surprised and very pleased,” she said.

Seeger, an accomplished performer and songwriter in her own right, said she was delighted to be revisiting a song “Ewan and I sang together for decades” at the Salford festival.

A new orchestral version of the song, created by Seeger with her son Neill MacColl and the BBC Philharmonic documentary, will also feature in a documentary which has been made by the festival in collaboration with BBC Archive on 4.

The film, which is presented by BBC Radio Manchester presenter and fellow Salford musician Mike Sweeney, will be broadcast on 6 July.

Source: Dirty Old Town: Folk anthem’s lost verse to be revealed

Martin Carthy narrates BBC radio documentary on “The Critics Group”

Ewan MacColl
Ewan MacColl

Immediately after the success of the BBC Radio Ballads, Ewan MacColl set about the Herculean task of trying to drag British folk music into mainstream culture. Frustrated by the dreary amateurishness of folk song performance, he decided to establish his own centre of excellence to professionalise the art. He called it “The Critics Group”.

MacColl tutored select artists “to sing folk songs the way they should be sung” and to think about the origins of what they were singing. He introduced Stanislavski technique and Laban theory into folk performance and explored style, content and delivery.

BBC producer Charles Parker recorded these sessions to aid group analysis. 40 years on, the tapes have come to light. For the first time, a clear sound picture can be constructed of this influential group in action. Former group members Peggy Seeger, Sandra Kerr, Frankie Armstrong, Richard Snell, Brian Pearson and Phil Colclough recount six frantic years of rehearsing, performing and criticising each other. They recall the powerful hold that Ewan MacColl exerted which was eventually to lead to the collapse of the group in acrimony and blame.

Presenter Martin Carthy MBE, now an elder statesman of the British folk music scene, shared many of McColl’s ambitions but didn’t join the group himself. He listens to the recordings and assesses the legacy of MacColl’s controversial experiment.Producers: Genevieve Tudor and Chris Eldon LeeA Culture Wise Production for BBC Radio 4.

LISTEN TO THE PROGRAM at : How Folk Songs Should Be Sung – BBC Sounds

Ewan MacColl: A biography by Peggy Seeger

Peggy Seeger’s biography of Ewan MacColl from Songmaker, published in 2001

William Miller [Ewan’s father] was a Scots iron-moulder, militant trade-unionist, active left-wing socialist and, by all accounts, a ‘sweet singer’ who had taken many a medal in singing competitions. In his early twenties he took one of his trophies to the pawnshop in Falkirk, where he met and fell in love with the young red-haired manageress.

One of fourteen children, Betsy Hendry was a fit and fiery mate for young Miller, who was at that time stumping the country with the Scots revolutionary John MacLean. These activities resulted in his being blacklisted in almost every foundry in Scotland. In 1910, the Millers moved to Salford (Lancashire) in search of work. Over the years, Betsy gave birth to four children, only one of whom survived: Jimmie.

Jimmie Miller grew up in a two-up/two-down house amongst a community of emigré Scots and from his earliest days he was as familiar with the cut-and-thrust of political discussion and argument as he was with the songs and stories his parents had brought from Scotland – a huge repertoire with which his father and mother kept themselves and their friends entertained. After an elementary education, Jimmie left school in 1930. The Great Depression was in full swing and he went straight into the army of the unemployed. His real education began during the Depression when, like many of the jobless, he sought warmth at the Manchester Public Library, where he spent most of his time reading. He occasionally got work as a motor-mechanic, factory worker, builders’ labourer, streetsinger – whatever he could put his hand and voice to. He joined the Workers’ Theatre but found it too pedestrian and conservative. Forming his own agit-prop street-performing group, the Red Megaphones, he thereafter devoted all of his waking hours for the next few years to theatrical and political activities.

Read more

The Folk on Foot Festival of LOVE!

14:00​ Nancy Kerr and James Fagan

14:05​ Heidi Talbot

14:20​ Seth Lakeman

14:35​ Lady Nade

14:50​ Kris Drever

15:05​ O’Hooley and Tidow

15:20​ Chris Wood

15:35​ Nancy Kerr and James Fagan

15:40​ Bella Hardy

15:55​ Sam Lee

16:10​ Rachel Newton

16:30​ Eliza Carthy

16:45​ Beth Porter and the Bookshop Band

17:00​ Gwilym Bowen Rhys

17:15​ Lisa Knapp and Gerry Diver

17:30​ Martin Simpson

17:45​ Kerry Andrew/You Are Wolf

18:00​ Seckou Keita

18:15​ Peggy Seeger

18:30​ Kitty Macfarlane

18:45​ The Breath

19:00​ Steve Knightley

19:15​ Karine Polwart

19:35​ Jon Boden

19:50​ Nancy Kerr and James Fagan

Donate to support the artists and the charity Help Musicians at https://www.folkonfoot.com/festival

💿 Buy CDs at our virtual merch tent at https://www.folkonfoot.com/festival

⌚ Running order (all times GMT and approximate)